Two separate arbitrations were filed by our office for a Chiropractor seeking reimbursement of wrongly denied medical bills for the treatment of an injured patient under the patient’s No-Fault Insurance policy. 

The first claim never went to arbitration and was settled for $6,700 (including chiropractic services and testing). 

The second claim went to arbitration and the Chiropractor was awarded the full reimbursement of treatments and services $9,788.20 plus interest and attorney’s fees. 

Our firm helped this one Chiropractor recover $16,488.20 plus interest and attorneys fees for one patient’s wrongly denied chiropractic treatments.

The arbitrator decided the second claim as follows: “An Applicant establishes its prima facie showing of entitlement to judgment as a matter of law by submitting evidentiary proof that the prescribed statutory billing forms had been mailed, received by the Respondent and that payment of no-fault benefits were overdue. Mary Immaculate Hospital v. Allstate Insurance Company, 5 A.D. 3d 742, 774 N.Y.S. 2d 564 ( 2ndDept. 2004 ). A facially valid claim has been defined as one that sets forth the name of the patient, date of the accident, date of service, description of services rendered, and the charges for those services. ( See, Vinnings Spinal Diagnostic P.C. v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Company,186 Misc. 2d 287; 717 NYS2d 466 ) 

The burden then shifts to the Respondent to prove that the services were not medically necessary. Amaze Medical Supply a/a/o Bermudez v. Eagle Insurance, 2 Misc. 3d 128 , 784 N.Y.S.2d 918 (2003). 

Once the insurer makes a sufficient showing to carry its burden of coming forward with evidence of lack of medical necessity, “ must rebut it or succumb.” ( See, Bedford

Park Med. Practice P.C. v American Transit Tr. Ins. Co., 8 Misc. 3d 1025 (A), 2005, 2005 NY

Slip Op 51282 citing Bauman v Long Island Railroad, 110AD2d 739, 741, ). 

As a general rule, reliance on rebuttal documentation will be weighed in light of the documentary

proofs and arguments presented at the arbitration. Moreover, the case law is clear that a provider

must rebut the conclusions and determinations of the IME doctor with his own facts. Park Slope

Medical and Surgical Supply, Inc. v. Travelers Ins. Co., 37 Misc.3d 19 (App. Term 2d, 11th &

13th Dists. 2012)

Following a thorough review of all the medical documentation submitted in this matter which

includes all physician evaluations, follow-up reports, and the IME report, I find these physicians

are in direct contradiction to one another. I am, of course, mindful that each of these experts has

a distinct interest and/or possible bias for his or her conclusions. That being said, the Applicant

contends that the services rendered were medically necessary.

The Respondent contends otherwise. The Arbitrator is thus placed in the position of determining

which of these opinions, (both of which on the surface appear credible and cogent), should be

accorded the most weight.

Here, there is extensive diagnostic testing of this EIP which demonstrate, among other things,

disc herniation at L3/L4, L4/5 with impingement of the ventral thecal sac on both, along with

significant cervical findings.

The IME examiner, on the other hand, has positive findings upon testing EIP’s range of motion,

both cervical and lumbar and he reviews the positive MRIs, all of which he ignores in deciding

that EIP requires no further treatment. The applicant examines EIP the following day and also

finds significant restrictions in ROM.

Applicant Is Awarded Reimbursement Of $9,788.20 Together With

Interest And Attorney’s Fees.

What Our Clients Are Saying

Based on 297 reviews
powered by Google
Amber PalermoAmber Palermo
17:50 23 Dec 22
The professionalism and expertise of the TonaLaw team is unmatched. I’ve worked with Juliet and she was incredibly knowledgeable, friendly and I could tell that she cared about helping me. If you’re looking for a legal team that helps with you any problem, big or small, TonaLaw is a team you can trust.
Regan moriartyRegan moriarty
16:49 23 Dec 22
The TonaLaw team is full of wonderful and hardworking people. I have personally worked with Juliet and she is excellent. You can tell she truly cares about the work she is doing. Highly recommend.
Elizabeth MartinezElizabeth Martinez
15:42 16 Dec 22
I can not be thankful enough for the amazing experience Tonalaw has given me from the very beginning. If you are looking for a lawyer who truly cares about your case then TonaLaw is for you. The amount of time and dedication they put in a case really shows how above and beyond they go. Not to mention how sweet everyone is really makes it a pleasure to work with TonaLaw.
Beatrice CestaroBeatrice Cestaro
22:06 14 Dec 22
I am extremely satisfied and happy to have chosen Tonal Law . The whole experience was flawless And I had absolutely no issues throughout the entire process. Everyone was so helpful and on time with everything, answered any questions I had, and we’re always easily available if I had any concerns. I basically did not have to lift a finger or do absolutely anything at all but answer a few questions. I put my full trust into Tona Law and I’m happy I did so. Would for sure recommend to any of my family and friends.
Anita AbramsAnita Abrams
21:14 05 Dec 22
Tona Law was an absolute pleasure to work with. As a local ART and Custom Framing resource, we helped to enhance their new offices, with beautiful and sophisticated, well curated artwork. Tom and his team were closely involved in all of the selections, and the environment is warm and friendly, as a result. Everyone at Tona Law, is considerate and professional.
Dawn DemartinoDawn Demartino
16:25 11 May 22
From start to finish I was informed every step of the way of the status and updates of my case… the time and steps taken to resolve my case in the best possible outcome was just one of the many great things Tonalaw provided. Personal care and commitment is top notch. Thank you !!
Louis B.Louis B.
15:27 08 Apr 22
Over the last few years Tona Law has guided me through the process with clear communication throughout. They are truly a client advocate and will do everything in the best interest of the client. Cannot thank them enough for all their work done for me.
Richard WoolleyRichard Woolley
19:49 26 Mar 22
Tom Tona and his team are fantastic. They do a great job for their clients. Can't recommend them highly enough.
Stacy LofredoStacy Lofredo
23:41 24 Mar 22
Tona Law has simplified no fault medical billing in a way that allows staff to effortlessly navigate through what could be a confusing process. Their staff is knowledgeable and responsive that we never have to worry about the ever-changing regulations because they are on top of keeping up to date with any changes in keeping their clients informed which is priceless!
Ruben ReyesRuben Reyes
15:29 13 Aug 21
They responded right away and were very professional. Brittany Reyes was very helpful. Thank you for your help
Randy RodriguezRandy Rodriguez
03:24 09 Aug 21
Would highly recommend if anyone is seeking any legal advice!